Another unexpected one! It appears the sweater is blue in the magazine ad while the book cover is purple. The model's eyes are the same color in both, just a difference in saturation. While the image works perfectly well for both, it's the book cover for me hands down, so much more simple!
Which is your favorite?
Thanks to Melissa Walker and the Ravenous Reader for sharing this one with me!
The Shrinking Violet one is my favorite. I don't want to think of the cover as a cold sore ad. Now it will be in my head when I look at the cover. Not a pleasant thought.
ReplyDeleteDefinitely the book cover! I'm amazed at your great eye!
ReplyDeleteLOL! I will laugh it anyone says: "I LIKE the cold sore ad better."
ReplyDeleteHow funny!
The book clearly is the best one!
ReplyDeleteI notice they made some work around the eyes, too!
Count me in for the book cover too. The girl in the cold sore ad actually looks like she's been squashed a little...!
ReplyDeleteHaha, I love the cold sore ad!
ReplyDeleteThe book definitely. her cheeks are all squished in the ad!
ReplyDeleteIt's interesting how they added or didn't remove the wrinkles from the cold sore ad. I'm guessing they're aiming that one at an older demographic.
ReplyDeleteI don't know how you spot these! I'm so impressed!
Definitely the book cover!
ReplyDeleteThe book cover looks nicer, mostly because of the colors. Also the Abreva advertisement has a much older looking woman on it? I guess her eye wrinkles (I love eye wrinkles FYI) had to get smoothed out for a YA book!
ReplyDeleteI like Shrinking Violet. The other one looks like the pictures was stretched in a weird way.
ReplyDeleteHa, I posted about this awhile ago.
ReplyDeleteBack in March, I did a post on this. I was looking through a magazine and there was that cold sore ad! I thought it was hilarous. If anyone wants to see the magazine version, here's a link: http://wwwsimplymegan.blogspot.com/2009/03/look-familiar.html
ReplyDeleteThat is too funny! I like the violet one but not because one is a cold sore ad, but because the over all effect is more integrated.
ReplyDeleteThe book cover is better, definitely :)
ReplyDeleteIt isn't exactly the same, but the paperback cover of AT FACE VALUE by Emily Franklin look similar to these. Minus the eyes and the playfulness.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.amazon.com/At-Face-Value-Emily-Franklin/dp/0738713074
*looks similar to these.
ReplyDelete=D
I love the book cover. I think it's so sweet and pretty. The ad doesn't take away from that for me. It actually made me like the ad more!
ReplyDeleteI prefer the book cover.
ReplyDeleteUmmm. Hands down - I'll take a shrinking violet over a cold sore any day!
ReplyDeleteI find it funny that the cold sore ad eyes have wrinkles. book cover for me!
ReplyDeleteLove the Shrinking Violet cover. These are so funny--I saw the Abreva ad a while ago, and just cracked up. Don't you think someone would notice repeating photos?
ReplyDeleteOhh I love the first one.. :)
ReplyDelete:) How did you find this one?? :)
ReplyDeleteCool find!
ReplyDeleteI can't tell if those were wrinkles that got taken out or two different poses, one where she was squishing her face a little.
I saw this one too and meant to tell you but then I couldn't remember what the ad was for...LOL But yes, the book is my favorite.
ReplyDelete-Lauren
I love the book cover version better, but it is funny my godchild is not interested in reading Shrinking Violet anymore???
ReplyDeleteI am going to copy the cover you have mentioned here .. the purple one.. and I am linking back to ths post as well.. :)
ReplyDeletei hope you dnt mind!
The book of course!
ReplyDelete